"Less is more," a phrase first written in a poem by Robert Browning in 1855, has a different meaning to everyone. To those who read the Browning poem Andrea del Sarto, it can explain artistic minimalism in a true minimalistic fashion. To others, it can refer to the title of artist Natasha Bedingfield's 2011 North American tour, "Less is More Tour." To me, it refers to teaching more by using less.
NJ Standard 1.1.12.B.1 states "Examine how aspects of meter, rhythm, tonality, intervals, chords, and harmonic progressions are organized and manipulated to establish unity and variety in genres of musical compositions." While this standards resides in 1.1 "The Creative Process" it implies using teaching methods that sit more with 1.3 "Performance." The only way to authentically meet this standard is to lead students in genuine performance of world musics. Instead of conducting a band in 3 concerts of western music each year, I suggest teachers explore music written for other ensembles to teach students. True musicians understand music, not solely western music. How else can a student truly understand this long list of musical ideas?
How can you possibly teach so many cultures in one year? You can't. Pick one each year. By the time your students finish in your program they will have a broader view of music and also of the world. Teaching through performance guarantees that student's will not be as affected by stereotypes seen through technology. Let's face it; there is a point where computers just can't do what humans can do.
To stay on my theme of Less Is More, I will end this post in under 300 words to be sincere in my post without diving in much deeper.
Related Article
Wednesday, March 28, 2012
Wednesday, March 21, 2012
Copyright vs. technology
The biggest problem with music technology is copyright infringement. It is commonly accepted among musicians that YouTube is both the greatest and most detrimental technology in the musical world. Almost everything posted on the media website is infringing on some part of the US copyright law, but most of these infringements are allowed to remain on the site. Why? Free promotion. Here's another blog post from another source on the issue.
Blog
Blog
Interactivity 4
Spreadsheet
I
choose this lesson plan because it can draw cross-curricular ties with other
subjects and current changing education policy. While the lesson is, as written
on the website, not only boring but severely lacking in educational value, with
the addition of asking students to write their own music it becomes immediately
relevant. Many genres of popular music rely on little to no notation, which is
an outcome of this lesson. Students will compose their own pieces without
musical notation. In addition, students must understand the function of lyrics
in the genre. This could also tie into a social justice unit a music teacher
may choose to teach (a common unit focus in the music classroom). The gaps
between the three columns of information were bridged with the addition of the
final piece of the lesson plan, the composition of music. The use of technology
acts as the backbone of the lesson. With that in mind a clear curriculum goal
was established while hitting on numerous standards and using both methods of
teaching strategies. The technologies used are commonplace in today's classroom
and do not require much preparation, another reason I chose this lesson. I am
always aware of the problems technology comes with and understand that a
back-up plan is always necessary. It is however essential to teaching this
curriculum goal; without technology, students of music would continue believing
they are the best performers they have ever heard. Without exposure to performers
through media technologies, students would not be able to learn anything about
performing.
Tuesday, February 28, 2012
Interactivity #3
Music
is a subject that not only embraces technology but almost requires technology.
In order to run a band rehearsal an electronic tuner, a CD or other playback
device, and other ways of amplification are necessities. In the general music
classroom, lessons can be fully reliant on technology. A teacher who doesn't
use some kind of technology can't truly be teaching music (instruments are
technically a technology).
While
the basic technologies listed in our inventory are beneficial, we collectively
ran out of technologies after a while. You can group many of the technologies
into categories like "Mac Apps," "Video games," and
"Recording software." Many of the technologies we listed were similar
or almost exactly the same as other technologies. I don’t believe I will
use most of these technologies in my classroom as I feel most of them inhibit
learning. Using a computer notation software allows students to rely on
prefabricated sounds instead of training their ears to hear the notes. YouTube
can be a great tool to expose children but more often than not ends up giving a
false understanding, not to mention most performances on YouTube are not good
performances. I would obviously use metronomes and tuners, but I’m not sure all
of our fancy teaching assistance technologies help us; I fear they allow
teachers to know less and allow a textbook or other source to teach a class for
them.
Monday, February 13, 2012
Interactivity 2: The Phonograph
The technology I feel that has had the greatest impact on
music education is the phonograph. Invented in 1877 by New Jersey’s own Thomas
Edison (whom I share a birthday with), the phonograph allowed not only for
sound to be recorded, but also allowed playback of recorded sound. Before the
introduction of the phonograph, students of music spent hours during their
studies traveling to cities and concert halls to hear music being performed
live just to take notes and learn a thing or two about music. J. S. Bach once
traveled 280 miles through Germany to hear Dietrich Buxtehude play a recital
and ended up staying several months to train with the organist. The phonograph
and recorded music paved the way for contemporary music education and public
school music education.
The invention of the phonograph allowed music to come to the
classroom. A new group of recording musicians, who we now call
ethnomusicologists, emerged and began traveling the world to record the music
they heard in different cultures. One such recorder, Frances Densmore, took a
liking to Native Americans. Her work recording the sounds of Native Americans
brought a new light to a population largely misunderstood. She recorded songs
used for rituals and praise, but more interestingly recorded sounds that the
Native Americans used in every day speech. This was not only important for
those studying music but also ethnologists, anthropologists and psychologists
in understanding the culture of Native American tribes.
Such recordings were not accepted by all, however. There
were many, as Vanessa Domine calls them, “protectionists” who felt recording
music took away from live musicing process one can only truly engage with in
real time. While this is true, recording has an educational benefit that is left
out of this argument. Before recordings were available, students relied on
their own interpretation for much of what they learned. Music education was
something that happened outside the classroom and was seldom taken seriously.
It wasn’t until mid-20th century that music education began emerging
in the schools, and even then it differs greatly from what we call music
education today. Recording has almost become synonymous with music today and
the way people access music has almost reversed. When recordings were first
made available, they only appealed to devout musicians and music lovers. Today,
it is much simpler to download the newest song instantly through the air to a
computer or other electronic device, and it is much more difficult (and much
more expensive) to see that music performed live by the artist(s).
While I believe the phonograph was a useful tool and
recordings enhance learning to this day, it can be argued that it also
destroyed music education. Bringing recordings to the students can be listed as
a reason for the “entitlement” students feel they have due to the privileges
and luxuries in the classroom. Likewise, students no longer have to put any
effort into hearing the best musicians perform the best repertoire. While this
opens up more time for practice and study, it lessens the value of the music;
you’re more likely to appreciate music you walk 280 miles to hear than music
you can download with the click of a button.
As I have argued, the phonograph and general recording has
had an enormous impact on music education. Since it’s invention, music has
become a highly recorded art, for the sake of distribution and profit. Before
recording, one could take pride in truly experiencing the musicing process and,
while music has never been free of political or economic influence, feel that
music is truly free and written for all people. However, recording music has
contributed to an interdisciplinary focus on bringing the world to the
classroom for students to truly engage and understand people from around the
world. Recorded music is the difference between private and public music
education; while private music education revolves around the student’s
performance, public music education relies on existing performance and
understanding music as an academic subject.
Picture is in my last post
Interactivity #2: Picture
"A studio recording is perfection, but emotion and passion come only when you turn on the machine and go for the groove." -Chuck Mangione
Wednesday, February 8, 2012
Digital Language: helpful, or hinderance?
With the creation of the digital world, we have also seen the creation of a digital language. When English was originally written, it was spoken almost the same as it was written. The tradition continued but eventually dialects emerged while the written text remained the same. Even today, we hold a traditional way of communicating through more formal digital means, but we now have three ways of conversing: talking, formal digital (used for academia) and informal digital (used in text messaging and the like). On top of that, many people speak different dialects to many people.
If a stranger was to walk into Chapin Hall on any given day, they may be surprised by the seemingly illiterate students shouting fragments at the top of their lungs. A literacy has risen out of my own friend circle, that of the awful grammer and ear-piercing yelps. Each of us has our own twang on the slang, mine including phrases like "vasdas?" meaning "what is this?" and "you do tings?" meaning anything from "did you eat yet?" to "did you do the homework?" or even "have you studied this music?" Most of my friends, in addition, have their own buzzwords. Samples of these words include "HEP!" "Lady?" yayyy!" and "brrbrbrbrbrbrbrbbr"
What does all this mean? We have many ways of communicating with people, and digital communication is probably the farthest from "correct" English. While I type this blog (with some mistakes I'm sure) I am using a type of English that any literate adult in the country, perhaps even the world, would understand. However, if I was writing this homework in a text message, i wouldnt care enough to type correct grammer everywhere haha lol :D. One reason for this other digital language can be blamed on the physical nature of cell phones: typing fully with the thumbs is a complete role-reversal from typing on a computer keyboard, and is frankly awkward and painful after any set amount of time. I often find myself typing just with my right index setting my phone on a flat surface to relieve the pain.
It is important to consider this type of communication when referencing technology in the classroom. Many professors advocate for the use of digital media, using technology for answering homework questions, using remote controls and personal computers in the classroom. I would have to understand my students well before I implement such technology and be prepared for the answers I receive. While someone may not speak derogatory or intolerant words, they may feel comfortable when they can use an outlet (technology) for these feelings. I fear that the informal digital dialect could be something to consider deeply before using technology.
If a stranger was to walk into Chapin Hall on any given day, they may be surprised by the seemingly illiterate students shouting fragments at the top of their lungs. A literacy has risen out of my own friend circle, that of the awful grammer and ear-piercing yelps. Each of us has our own twang on the slang, mine including phrases like "vasdas?" meaning "what is this?" and "you do tings?" meaning anything from "did you eat yet?" to "did you do the homework?" or even "have you studied this music?" Most of my friends, in addition, have their own buzzwords. Samples of these words include "HEP!" "Lady?" yayyy!" and "brrbrbrbrbrbrbrbbr"
What does all this mean? We have many ways of communicating with people, and digital communication is probably the farthest from "correct" English. While I type this blog (with some mistakes I'm sure) I am using a type of English that any literate adult in the country, perhaps even the world, would understand. However, if I was writing this homework in a text message, i wouldnt care enough to type correct grammer everywhere haha lol :D. One reason for this other digital language can be blamed on the physical nature of cell phones: typing fully with the thumbs is a complete role-reversal from typing on a computer keyboard, and is frankly awkward and painful after any set amount of time. I often find myself typing just with my right index setting my phone on a flat surface to relieve the pain.
It is important to consider this type of communication when referencing technology in the classroom. Many professors advocate for the use of digital media, using technology for answering homework questions, using remote controls and personal computers in the classroom. I would have to understand my students well before I implement such technology and be prepared for the answers I receive. While someone may not speak derogatory or intolerant words, they may feel comfortable when they can use an outlet (technology) for these feelings. I fear that the informal digital dialect could be something to consider deeply before using technology.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
